Authentication Is Non-Negotiable
Email authentication proves to receiving mail servers that a message really comes from the domain it claims. Unauthenticated email is far more likely to be filtered or rejected.Complete Your Domain Setup
Every sending domain in Lettr needs DKIM and DMARC records, plus SPF for a root domain or a CNAME for a subdomain:Lettr provides the exact DNS record values when a domain is added. Copy them exactly. Even a small difference causes verification to fail. See Sending Domains for the full setup guide.
Set Up a Tracking Domain
Using a custom tracking domain (e.g.,track.yourdomain.com) instead of a shared tracking domain improves deliverability. Links in your emails then use your own domain, which builds reputation under your brand rather than sharing it with other senders.
See Tracking Domains for setup instructions.
Warm Up New Domains
Mailbox providers treat new sending domains with suspicion, and a large volume from a domain with no history is likely to be filtered. Warming up means gradually increasing volume so providers can observe consistent, legitimate behavior. The week-by-week volume schedule is in IP and Domain Warm-Up.Warm-Up Tips
- Start with engaged recipients: Send first to users who regularly open and click your emails. Positive engagement signals help establish reputation.
- Be consistent: Send every day during warm-up. Sporadic large sends look suspicious.
- Watch your metrics: Rising bounce or complaint rates are the signal to slow down and investigate before continuing. The thresholds are in IP and Domain Warm-Up.
Maintain Clean Recipient Lists
Mailbox providers monitor bounce and complaint rates and throttle or block senders with poor list hygiene, which makes invalid or unengaged addresses one of the fastest ways to damage deliverability.Process Bounces Immediately
Hard bounces mean the address is permanently undeliverable. Continuing to send to hard-bounced addresses signals to mailbox providers that you don’t maintain your lists. Set up a webhook to handle bounce events in real time:Use Double Opt-In
Confirm subscriptions before adding addresses to your list. With double opt-in, an address joins the sending list only after its owner clicks a unique link in a confirmation email, which proves the address is valid and that the owner wants your emails.Remove Unengaged Subscribers
Mailbox providers use engagement signals (opens, clicks) to decide inbox placement, and recipients who never open your emails weaken those signals. Periodically remove or re-engage subscribers who haven’t interacted in 6 to 12 months.Content That Avoids Spam Filters
Content affects deliverability on its own, even with complete authentication and a clean list.Subject Lines
Email Body
Required Footer Elements
Every marketing and bulk email should include:- Unsubscribe link: One-click unsubscribe is now required by major providers
- Physical mailing address: Required by CAN-SPAM
- Reply-to address: Allows recipients to respond
Monitor Your Metrics
Track these key indicators to catch problems early:Open rates are increasingly unreliable due to Apple Mail Privacy Protection and other privacy features that pre-fetch images. Use click rates and direct engagement as more reliable indicators. See Open & Click Tracking Accuracy for details.
Sending Reputation
Mailbox providers like Gmail, Outlook, and Yahoo assign a reputation to every sender based on observed behavior, and that reputation decides how your future emails are treated. For what reputation is and how providers evaluate it, see Email Deliverability.Signals to Watch
Beyond the metrics above, providers also weigh these signals:- Spam trap hits: Sending to addresses that exist only to catch spammers. Any hit points to a list-quality problem, usually an old, purchased, or scraped list.
- Authentication results: Every message should pass DKIM and DMARC. See Authentication.
- Sending consistency: Stable day-to-day volume reads as legitimate. Sudden spikes or long gaps look suspicious.
Lettr doesn’t expose a single reputation score. Monitor the individual signals: bounce and open rates on the dashboard, spam complaint counts on the Analytics page, and webhook data (
message.bounce, message.spam_complaint, message.delay, engagement.open, engagement.click).Domain vs IP Reputation
Reputation attaches to both your sending domain and the IP address that delivers your email. Most major providers, Gmail in particular, weigh domain reputation heavily, and it’s the part you control through your own sending practices. On shared IPs, your IP reputation is also influenced by other senders on the same infrastructure. See Dedicated vs Shared IPs for when a dedicated IP makes sense.Separate Streams by Subdomain
Each subdomain builds its own reputation. Transactional and marketing email on one shared domain also share one reputation, so a poorly received campaign can delay password resets and order confirmations. At a minimum, send each type from its own subdomain:
Add each subdomain as a separate sending domain in Lettr, configure the records Lettr shows for it, and wait for it to be verified before sending. See Subdomain vs Root Domain for more guidance.
Recovering from Reputation Damage
Spam placement, falling delivery rates and rising deferrals are all recoverable, but recovery is slow. Work through these steps in order.1
Reduce your sending volume immediately
Cut volume to 10-20% of your current level. Sending at full volume while your reputation is damaged makes things worse with every send.
2
Identify and fix the root cause
Common causes include:
- Sending to a purchased or scraped list
- Failing to process bounces, leading to repeated sends to invalid addresses
- A spike in spam complaints after a poorly targeted campaign
- Broken authentication (DKIM/DMARC failures)
message.bounce, message.spam_complaint, and message.delay events to pinpoint the issue.3
Clean your recipient list aggressively
Remove all hard-bounced addresses, all spam complainants, and anyone who hasn’t engaged in the last 6 months.
4
Send only to your most engaged recipients
Restrict sending to recipients who opened or clicked within the last 30 days. Positive engagement is what rebuilds reputation.
5
Gradually increase volume
Follow the warm-up schedule linked above. Increase volume only while bounce rate stays below 2% and complaint rate below 0.1%.
6
Monitor daily until metrics stabilize
Check your dashboard and webhook data every day. Recovery typically takes 2 to 6 weeks of consistently good behavior, depending on the severity of the damage.
Warning Signs
Increasing deferrals
Increasing deferrals
A growing number of
message.delay events means receiving servers are delaying your emails instead of accepting them. This is often the first sign a provider is losing trust in your domain. Check which providers are deferring and whether it correlates with a volume increase or a change in your recipient list.Sudden drop in open rates
Sudden drop in open rates
A sharp decline, especially at one provider like Gmail or Outlook, usually means your emails are being routed to spam. Test with a seed account at the affected provider to confirm inbox placement.
Bounce rate creeping up
Bounce rate creeping up
A gradually rising bounce rate means your list is aging. Without real-time processing of
message.bounce events, stale addresses accumulate and add to the reputation damage. Confirm suppression is working.Spam placement at one provider only
Spam placement at one provider only
Inbox placement at most providers but spam at one means that provider has flagged your domain, often because your complaint rate crossed its threshold. Reduce volume to that provider, send only to engaged recipients there, and confirm DKIM and DMARC pass. See Emails Landing in Spam.
Testing Before Sending
Pre-Send Checklist
- Send test emails: Send to yourself and colleagues across different email clients (Gmail, Outlook, Apple Mail)
- Check rendering: Verify your email looks correct on both desktop and mobile
- Verify links: Click every link in the test email to confirm they work
- Review content: Read through for spam trigger words and formatting issues
- Validate authentication: Check email headers to confirm DKIM is passing
Common Deliverability Issues
Emails going to spam
Emails going to spam
- Verify all authentication records (DKIM, DMARC) are passing
- Review your email content for spam triggers
- Check that you have a visible unsubscribe link
- Ensure your domain has built sufficient reputation (warm up if new)
- See Emails Landing in Spam for step-by-step diagnosis
High bounce rate
High bounce rate
- Implement double opt-in for new subscribers
- Validate email addresses at the point of collection
- Remove subscribers who haven’t engaged in 6+ months
- Process bounce webhooks immediately instead of in batches
- See Bounce Diagnosis for interpreting bounce codes
Low open rates
Low open rates
- Test different approaches to subject lines
- Send at times when your audience is most active
- Segment your audience for more relevant content
- Remove unengaged subscribers to improve overall metrics
- Check if Apple MPP is inflating or deflating your numbers
Emails delayed or deferred
Emails delayed or deferred
- Check if you’re sending too fast during domain warm-up
- Verify your domain reputation hasn’t been damaged
- Look for
message.delaywebhook events for specific reasons - Expect some delays, since receiving servers may throttle new senders
Related Topics
Email Deliverability
What deliverability is and how it’s measured
List Hygiene
Maintain healthy recipient lists
Domain Setup
Configure and verify your sending domains
Bounces
Understand bounce types and handling